<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none;" alt="" src="https://px.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=5133266&amp;fmt=gif">

What is the Difference between shop drawings and construction drawings?​

What is the Difference between shop drawings and construction drawings?​

In the intricate world of construction, understanding the differences between shop drawings and construction drawings is paramount. Both are essential, yet they serve distinct purposes and arise from different stages of a project. This guide aims to clarify these differences, offering insight into how each type of drawing contributes to the successful completion of construction projects.

What Are Shop Drawings?

Shop drawings are highly detailed plans created by contractors, fabricators, and manufacturers. These drawings focus on the specifics required for the fabrication, assembly, or installation of particular components within a construction project. Unlike the broader design documents prepared by architects and engineers, shop drawings provide explicit instructions tailored to the project's unique elements.

Shop drawings include:

  • Dimensions: Exact measurements of the components.
  • Material specifications: Information on materials to be used.
  • Fabrication details: Instructions on how to fabricate or assemble the parts.
  • Installation procedures: Guidelines for how components should be installed at the construction site.
  • Coordination with other systems: Information on how the component fits within the overall building systems.

As a rule of thumb, the cost of shop drawings should be roughly around 5% of the total budget of construction.

Why Do Contractors Need Shop Drawings?

Shop drawings serve several essential functions in the construction process, each contributing to the project's overall success.

1. Clarifying Design Intent

Shop drawings provide a more detailed and precise interpretation of the design, going beyond the general guidelines set in the architectural or engineering drawings.

2. Coordination among Trades

Construction projects involve multiple trades (e.g., electrical, plumbing, HVAC), and shop drawings ensure that all systems fit together without conflicts.

3. Customization and Fabrication

Many components of a building, such as custom steel beams, windows, or HVAC systems, need to be fabricated specifically for the project. Shop drawings provide the exact dimensions and materials required, ensuring that the fabricated elements match the project specifications.

4. Quality Control

Shop drawings serve as a quality control tool by providing contractors, project managers, and inspectors with a reference to ensure that construction follows the approved design.

5. Avoiding Errors and Rework

By detailing the specifics of fabrication and installation, shop drawings reduce the risk of errors during construction. This can save time and money by minimizing costly rework, delays, and material waste.

Benefits of Shop Drawings

The advantages of using shop drawings are numerous and impactful on any construction project.

  • Clarification of design: Provide detailed, accurate interpretations of architectural and engineering plans.
  • Enhanced coordination: Ensure seamless integration between different trades (e.g., electrical, plumbing, HVAC).
  • Customization and precision: Offer specific details for custom fabrication and installation.
  • Error reduction: Minimize the likelihood of construction errors, saving time and costs.
  • Quality control: Serve as a reference for verifying that work meets project standards and specifications.
  • Code compliance: Ensure that construction follows building codes and safety regulations.
  • Efficient approval process: Allow for review and approval by architects/engineers before construction or fabrication begins.
  • Cost and time savings: Reduce the need for rework and delays by providing clear instructions upfront.

What Are Construction Drawings?

Construction drawings are comprehensive technical documents that outline the specifications and visual representations of a building project. They include architectural, structural, mechanical, electrical, and plumbing elements, serving as a guide for contractors and builders.

Architectural Components

Construction drawings detail the architectural elements of a project, including floor plans, elevations, and sections. This provides a clear visual representation of the building's design.

Structural Elements

The structural integrity of a building is outlined in construction drawings, detailing components like beams, columns, and foundations.

Why Do Architects Need Construction Drawings?

Construction drawings are indispensable for several reasons, each contributing to the successful completion of a project.

Clear Communication

These drawings serve as a visual representation of the project, ensuring all stakeholders understand the design intent and can work collaboratively.

Accurate Measurements

Precise dimensions and specifications for materials are detailed in construction drawings, minimizing errors during construction.

Code Compliance

Construction drawings ensure the project meets local building codes and safety standards, avoiding legal issues and ensuring the safety of occupants.

Construction drawings play a crucial role in project coordination, cost estimation, and overall project management.

Differences between Shop Drawings and Construction Drawings

Understanding the distinctions between shop drawings and construction drawings is vital for anyone involved in construction.

Who Is Responsible for Creating These Drawings?
  • Construction Drawings are typically created by architects or engineers at the owner's request. They outline the overall design and specifications for the project.
  • Shop Drawings are produced by contractors, subcontractors, manufacturers, or suppliers after a contract is signed. They focus on the specifics of fabrication and installation.
When Are They Created??
  • Construction Drawings are developed before actual construction begins, serving as the foundation for the project.
  • Shop Drawings are generated before construction starts, derived from contract drawings and project specifications.
The purpose of producing these drawings?

Construction drawings

  • These drawings provide accurate, detailed specifications of architectural elements, supported by graphical representations for precise decision-making.
  • They depict the progress and final outcome of the construction work.
  • Construction drawings account for structural functionality, appearance, estimated dimensions, fixtures, materials, equipment performance, and connections to other building systems.
  • They serve as bid drawings, enabling contractors to estimate project costs, including labor, materials, and overall construction expenses.

Shop drawings

  • These sets of drawings interpret the actual design intent, field conditions, and information for fabricators to achieve accurate coordination, fabrication, assembly, and installation.
  • They ensure all the elements are fabricated and assembled to industry specifications and codes and are also known as prefabrication drawings.
  • Shop drawings are a greater elaboration of construction drawings as they include detailed components like beams, trusses, etc. to equipment and various layouts.
  • Every sub-contractor produces its own set of shop drawings for approval.
Aspect Shop Drawings Construction Drawings
Purpose Detailed drawings for fabrication and installation of specific components or systems General design intent for the entire construction project
Who Creates Typically created by contractors, fabricators, or manufacturers Created by architects and engineers (design team)
When Created After the construction drawings are issued, during the construction phase Created during the design phase, before construction starts
Level of Detail Very detailed, specific to components like HVAC ducts, steel beams, or electrical systems Broad and conceptual, focusing on overall structure and design
Content Includes precise dimensions, material specifications, fabrication details, and installation instructions Includes floor plans, elevations, sections, MEP layouts, and general specifications
Coordination Focuses on coordination between trades (e.g., MEP systems with structural elements) Provides overall coordination of the building’s structure and systems
Review and Approval Must be reviewed and approved by architects, engineers, and other design professionals Reviewed and approved by the client and authorities before construction begins
Liability Contractors/fabricators are typically responsible for the accuracy and compliance of shop drawings The design team (architects/engineers) is liable for the overall design integrity
Risk During Drafting Higher risk for contractors, as shop drawings must meet both design intent and practical constraints Lower risk, as construction drawings are conceptual and guide the general design
Legal Status Used as part of the contract documents after approval but more specific to individual components Serve as official contract documents guiding the entire construction projects

Conclusion

In large, complex construction projects, the importance of detailed plans cannot be overstated. Shop drawings and construction drawings are both integral to ensuring precision and successful project outcomes. Investing time and resources in these detailed drawings is crucial for any project's success.

At NY Engineers, we excel in providing shop drawing extraction services for a wide range of projects. With extensive experience, we've supported many professionals by delivering precise drawing extractions. Our shop drawings encompass various design components, offering comprehensive details for floor plans, window layouts, plumbing systems, HVAC designs, and more. For those interested in learning more, we invite you to explore these services and see how they can benefit your project.

Share:

What is the Difference between shop drawings and construction drawings?​

What is the Difference between shop drawings and construction drawings?​

Join 15,000+ Fellow Architects and Contractors

Get expert engineering tips straight to your inbox. Subscribe to the NY Engineers Blog below.